Showing posts with label bussho. Show all posts
Showing posts with label bussho. Show all posts

Saturday, October 08, 2011

The Truth of Buddha-Nature

The Truth of Buddha-Nature..

The truth of the buddha-nature is that we are not equipped with the buddha-nature before we realize the state of buddha; we are equipped with it following realization of the state of buddha. The buddha-nature and realization of buddha inevitably experience the same state together. We should thoroughly investigate and consider this truth.
Shobogenzo, Bussho, Gudo Nishijima & Mike Cross


Peace,
Ted

Thursday, April 28, 2011

Clear Demonstration of Buddha-Nature...


The Clear Demonstration of Buddha-Nature...


The fourteenth patriarch, the Venerable Ryuju, called Nagarjuna in Sanskrit, and called either Ryuju, Ryusho, or Ryumo in Chinese, is a man from western India, and he goes to southern India. Most people of that nation believe in karma for happiness. The Venerable One preaches for them the subtle Dharma. Those who hear him say to each other, “The most important thing in the human world is that people possess karma for happiness. Yet he talks idly of the buddha-nature. Who can see such a thing?”

The Venerable One says, “If you want to realize the buddha-nature, you must first get rid of selfish pride.”

The people say, “Is the buddha-nature big or is it small?”

The Venerable One says, “The buddha-nature is not big and not small, it is not wide and not narrow, it is without happiness and without rewards, it does not die and it is not born.”

When they hear these excellent principles, they all turn from their original mind. Then the Venerable One, from his seat, manifests his free body, which seems like the perfect circle of a full moon. All those gathered only hear the sound of Dharma; they do not see the master’s form. In that assembly is a rich man’s son, Kanadeva. He says to the assembly, “Do you know what this form is or not?”

Those in the assembly say, “The present [form] is something our eyes have never before seen, our ears have never before heard, our minds have never before known, and our bodies have never before experienced.”

Kanadeva says, “Here the Venerable One is manifesting the form of the buddha-nature to show it to us. How do we know this? It may be presumed that the formless state of samadhi in shape resembles the full moon. The meaning of the buddha-nature is evident and it is transparently clear.”

After these words, the circle disappears at once, and [the master] is sitting on his seat. Then he preaches the following verse:

[My] body manifests the roundness of the moon,
By this means demonstrating the physique of the buddhas.
The preaching of Dharma has no set form.
The real function is beyond sounds and sights.

(Quoted from Shobogenzo, Bussho, translated by Gudo Nishijima & Mike Cross)

This is a wonderfully rich Buddhist story. Anyone that takes the time to memorize it and carry it around with them probably find many subtle layers here… Let us simply consider one of these for now.

The great Buddhist ancestor Nagarjuna, the story goes, preaches the “subtle Dharma.” Those that hear him are surprised that his preaching fails to support their own presuppositions about the Dharma. According to the “common” view (in that place and time) the “most important thing” in the world was assumed to be good karma. Then, along comes Nagarjuna preaching about something as insignificant (in their view) as Buddha-nature.

Presuppositions – in a certain sense, the whole nature and function of authentic Buddhist practice-enlightenment is the undoing of presuppositions.

It is sometimes easy to dismiss or ignore words, thoughts, and deeds that fail to agree with our own presuppositions. Fortunately, “the people” in this story did not simply dismiss Nagarjuna and go home or back to their own temples; they questioned themselves (“What does he mean about Buddha-nature?”), and they questioned the master. What’s he saying? Is our own view about what is of greatest importance mistaken? Excellent Zen practice!

Nagarjuna said, ““If you want to realize the buddha-nature, you must first get rid of selfish pride.”

To get at the reality of “Buddha-nature” requires one to “first get rid of selfish pride.” That selfish pride can be very stubborn (and subtle) – the fact that “the people” did not simply dismiss Nagarjuna in the first place, but instead were willing to seriously inquire into his teaching (and thus their own views) seems to suggest that they were a little less attached to “selfish pride” than many of us are today.

What else can you reveal Nagarjuna? Let’s say that we are willing and able to rid ourselves of selfish pride and “realize” this “Buddha-nature” you speak of, what exactly will we be “realizing”? What is the Buddha-nature?

Nagarjuna said, “The buddha-nature is not big and not small, it is not wide and not narrow, it is without happiness and without rewards, it does not die and it is not born.”

Interesting, at first glance the Buddha-nature seems to NOT be a lot of things, and to be WITHOUT many qualities, and also does NOT DO various things – in short, it is NOT big and NOT small, NOT wide and NOT narrow, it is WITHOUT happiness and WITHOUT rewards, it does NOT die and it is NOT born.

Is this the same as “neti, neti” (not-this, not-this)? Certainly, some would argue thus. Just as the Buddhist teachings of emptiness are often used to support certain presuppositions about uniformity and non-differentiation, about non-existence and void oneness…

But does that account for the whole of Nagarjuna’s statement? Can we also read it like this:

“THE BUDDHA-NATURE IS not big AND not small, IT IS not wide AND not narrow, IT IS without happiness AND without rewards, IT DOES not die AND IT IS not born.”

If we can realize it like this the wisdom of this story may shine through and be as clear and present as a piece of fruit held in the palm of our hand. And why wouldn’t it be? The Buddhas and ancestors reveal and express the Dharma – they never conceal or begrudge. To realize what the Buddha-nature IS, and DOES we must first be rid of selfish pride – and then we realize, as Dogen says, “the buddha-nature is ‘transparently clear’ and is ‘evident.’”

The ancestral master does not begrudge them [the teaching], but their eyes and ears are shut and so they cannot see or hear it. Never having established body-knowing, they cannot make out [the teaching]. As they watch from afar “the formless state of samadhi” whose “shape resembles the full moon,” and as they do prostrations to it, it is “something their eyes have never before seen.” “The meaning of the buddha-nature is evident and it is transparently clear.” So the state in which the body manifesting itself preaches the buddha-nature is “transparently clear” and is “evident.” And the state in which the preaching of the buddha-nature is a body manifesting itself is “demonstration, by concrete means,” of “the physique of the buddhas.” Where could there be one buddha or two buddhas who failed to realize as “the buddha-physique” this “demonstration by concrete means”?
~Shobogenzo, Bussho, Gudo Nishijima & Mike Cross

It seems as if this was the reason that only Kanadeva (Nagarjuna’s successor) was able to see the Buddha’s body (physique of Buddha) at that time. Fortunately, this event was recorded and there have certainly been many beings that have been able to meet with Kanadeva and Nagarjuna since. This story is exerted by the liberating potential of the whole Buddha Dharma – carry it around and see if you don’t find the bare fact of the Buddha-nature shining right before you. Check in with Dogen’s commentary on the story from time to time (in Shobogenzo, Bussho) for a little help clearing your vision; there you will find many clues, like this gem for example:

Remember, at this time the Venerable One is simply seated upon his high seat. The manner in which his body manifests itself is just the same as in the case of any person seated here now.
~Shobogenzo, Bussho, Gudo Nishijima & Mike Cross
 

Peace,
Ted

Sunday, February 06, 2011

Realizing the True Nature of Yourself - Yes, "Self"


You need to discern and affirm for yourself the underlying meaning of his saying, “If you wish to see Buddha Nature, you must first rid yourself of your arrogant pride.” It is not that one lacks sight, but the seeing of which he spoke is based on ridding oneself of one’s arrogant pride. The arrogance of self is not just of one kind, and pride takes many forms. Methods for ridding oneself of these will also be diverse and myriad. Even so, all of these methods will be ‘one’s seeing Buddha Nature’. Thus, you need to learn both to look with your eyes and to see with your Eye.
Shobogenzo, Bussho, Hubert Nearman

Putting one’s trust in the authority of the true self is only grandiose and misguided if it is attempted with an inaccurate understanding. Driving a car or installing an electrical outlet with no more than a superficial understanding can be disastrous; pursuing the great matter of life and death under the authority of the true self without clearly understanding what that means would be seriously unwise.

Popular notions about individualistic forms of “personal Buddhism” illustrate how ridiculous things get with superficial views of Buddhism. Assertions that “my Zen” and “your Zen” or “your Dogen” and “my Dogen” are all “just Buddhism” are not at all what Dogen means by trusting the true self; to the contrary, such notions come only from the personal self, from bowing to the authority of ego. Such fanciful ideas are one reason Dogen was so vehemently opposed to notions of separate “sects” of Buddhism.

If the principle of setting up one’s own way was the authentic Way, the Buddha Dharma would have disappeared in India long ago. Who would honor principles that individual people had set up on their own? If each person sets up his own principles, who could determine which were true and which were false? What was true and what was false could never be determined. If the true and the false cannot be determined, who could recognize what was actually the Buddha Dharma? If its principles cannot be clarified, it would be difficult to call anything ‘the Way of the Buddha’.
Shobogenzo, Butsudo, Hubert Nearman


In Dogen’s Zen, just as each real dharma is a unique expression of the wholeness of existence-time, each real expression of Buddhism is a unique expression of the wholeness of Buddha Dharma. Buddhism is not our personal opinions about expressions of truth; Buddhism is the truth that is expressed. From the perspective of Shobogenzo, the uniqueness of human experience – its realm, personal self (ego), and relative depth and clarity – is attributed to the integral character resulting from the specific combination of causes and conditions expressing each individual existence.

By “integral character” I mean the natural or innate propensity toward experiencing the world; it is the integral character of owls to eat meat, not clover; it is the integral character of rabbits to avoid owls, not seek them out. Moreover, not only does a newborn tiger naturally advance to become an adult tiger, it advances to become the adult tiger inherent to its specific causes and conditions, its “integral character.” From the moment of conception (or, in Buddhist terms, from before the eon of emptiness) each human being perceives, and interacts with her experience in a manner that is organically consistent with her integral character.

If not directly inspired by the widespread dualistic views (mostly within the Shingon and Tendei traditions) based on distorted interpretations of “original enlightenment” (hongaku), Dogen’s emphasis on the teachings of nonduality was undoubtedly reinforced by these circumstances. In any case, Dogen’s refutation of such views are primarily aimed at undermining assumptions that human experience (hence, existence) is produced or “fashioned” by the world, rather than being the “fashioner” of the world. The owl egg is not haphazardly transformed by the world into an adult owl; the environment does contribute to conditioning this development, but it does not cause it.

Shobogenzo clearly distinguishes between the vision of prajna (enlightened wisdom) and common abstract, biased vision. Prajna is the active force of integral character, the center of gravity at the heart of the combined energies of the various causes and conditions that makes a human not only human, but that particular human. It is the “clear seeing” (prajna) that is the “fashioner” of a universe and the fashioner of a self that each human calls “myself.” In this sense, prajna is the working force that facilitates and informs the meaning and significance of the individual human being’s characteristic approach to and interaction with their experience of the world.

Shakyamuni Buddha once said in verse:

If any people give voice to this Discourse
Then they will surely be able to see Me.
But to express It for the sake of even one person
Is indeed something difficult for them to do.


So it follows from this that to be able to express the Dharma is to see Shakyamuni Buddha because, when ‘such a one’ comes to see ‘Me’, he is Shakyamuni Buddha.
Shobogenzo, Gyobutsu Iigi, Hubert Nearman

Seeing, hearing, smelling, tasting, touching [feeling], and thinking are the six streams that constitute human experience (thus, existence). These never-ceasing, ever-advancing streams are neither fixed, nor prearranged in particular forms or patterns; they are the random, chaotic, ceaseless manifestation of the one mind, the all inclusive realm of reality, the wholeness of existence-time common to all things and beings. This common reality is Buddha nature/mu-Buddha nature (more on this later); owl prajna actualizes it as an owl and an owl realm, tiger prajna as a tiger and a tiger realm, human prajna as a self and a universe.

The experience of this actualization by owls and tigers is known only to owls and tigers. For humans, however, this experience can only occur in one of two ways, actively or passively. Whether actively or passively all humans, being innately human, actualize a universe and a self from (“bits and pieces”) of the six streams of human experience. Active actualization is consciously directed prajna, intentionally enacted; passive actualization is the random, automatically functioning of prajna, unconscious and haphazard.

The Great Way that Buddha after Buddha has Transmitted has continued on without interruption, and the merits of training that Ancestor after Ancestor has revealed have spread far and wide…

At the same time, the inborn abilities of human beings are of many kinds. For instance, there are those who innately know what life really is. Once born, they free themselves from the sufferings and delusions of living. That is, through their own bodily existence they thoroughly master what life really is, beginning, middle, and end. And there are those who realize the Truth through learning. They undertake study and ultimately master themselves. In other words, they thoroughly exhaust the skin and flesh, bones and marrow of learning. And there are those who know what Buddha is. They go beyond those who realize the Truth through living and those who realize the Truth through learning. They transcend the bounds of self and other, are unbounded in the here and now, and are beyond having opinions when it comes to knowing self and other. That is to say, they have a knowledge that has no teacher. They are not dependent on a good spiritual friend, nor on Scriptural writings, nor on the nature of things, nor on external forms; they do not try to open up and turn themselves around, nor do they try to be interdependent with others; rather, they are completely transparent, with nothing hidden. Of these various types, do not conclude that one is smart and another dull. Each type fully manifests the merits from their training.

As a consequence, you would do well to explore through your training whether there are any beings, sentient or non-sentient, who cannot come to know the Truth simply by living their daily life. Any who have come to know the Truth through living life will have come to realize that Truth as the result of their living an everyday life. Once they have awakened to the Truth, they will reveal It in their everyday lives as they do their training and practice throughout their lives. Thus, the Buddhas and Ancestors, who are already Trainers and Tamers of Human Beings, have come to be called ‘Those who have fully realized what life really is’ because They have fully grasped what realization means. It will be your realization of what life is that leads you to partake of the great realization, because it will manifest from your study of Their realization.
Shobogenzo, Daigo, Hubert Nearman


If you are really doing your exploring through your training, whether by following the Scriptures or by following your spiritual friend, you will ultimately realize the Truth by yourself, independent of your Master. Realizing the Truth by oneself independent of one’s Master is the functioning of one’s True Nature. And even so, if you are inherently keen, you will still need to call upon a Master and inquire of the Way. And even if you are not inherently keen, you will still need to do your utmost in practicing the Way. But who among you is not inherently keen? Each one of you follows both the Scriptures and the advice of a good friend in order to arrive at the enlightenment which is the fruit of Buddhahood. Keep in mind that inherent keenness means that when you encounter the Scriptures or come face-to-face with a spiritual friend, you are encountering the meditative state of your True Nature, and that when you encounter the meditative state of your True Nature, you attain the meditative state of the True Nature of all things. It is our tapping into the wisdom from our previous lives, attaining the three illuminations, and awakening to fully perfected enlightenment. Coming face-to-face with our inherent keenness, we study it; coming face-to-face with the wisdom that goes beyond having a Master and that is inherent within us, we straightforwardly Transmit it. If we had no inherent keenness, then even though we came face-to-face with the Scriptures and a spiritual friend, we could not hear what the True Nature of all things is, nor could we realize It. The Great Truth is not a principle like that of someone drinking water to know for himself whether it is warm or cool.
…
Even were we to talk or converse as if we lacked True Nature, or were to work or act as if we lacked True Nature, this too would only be True Nature manifesting Itself. The passing of days and months of immeasurable eons past has been the passing of the True Nature of all things. And it is just the same for the present and the future. We may take the measure of our body and mind to be just the measure of our body and mind, not recognizing them as an aspect of our True Nature, but this way of thinking about them is also a function of our True Nature. Or we may take the measure of our body and mind not to be a true measure of our body and mind, while still not recognizing them as an aspect of our True Nature, but this way of thinking about them is likewise a function of our True Nature. Whatever we may consider or not consider them to be, in either case they are an aspect of our True Nature. To think that the ‘Nature’ in ‘True Nature’ means that water does not flow and that trees do not flourish and then wither away is a non-Buddhist view.

Shakyamuni Buddha once said, “The appearance of each thought and thing is just as it is, and the nature of each thought and thing is likewise just as it is.”
Shobogenzo, Hossho, Hubert Nearman


Meditation Master Setcho Juken once said, “The two Masters—Joshu and Bokushu—are examples of what it means to be an Old Buddha.” Accordingly, the words of Old Buddhas are Their awakened experience of Buddha Dharma and Their own personal ways of putting the Matter which They uttered in the past. Great Master Seppo Shinkaku once exclaimed, “Joshu, the Old Buddha!” A previous Ancestor of the Buddha also praised Joshu by eulogizing him as an Old Buddha, and a later Ancestor of the Buddha eulogized him as an Old Buddha as well. Obviously, they are saying that he is an Old Buddha who has gone beyond any spiritually awakened state attained by others of the past or present.
Shobogenzo, katto, Hubert Nearman

...
Peace,
Ted

Tuesday, July 13, 2010

Enlightenment Based On Enlightenment

Enlightenment Based On Enlightenment...

Continued from the post: Buddha Mind - Fences, Walls, Tiles, and Pebbles

Now then, if our existence is fashioned by “bits and pieces” of unceasing experience that “cannot be held onto,” it would obviously be a total waste of time and energy to endeavor to diminish or eradicate anything. The more effective approach is simply to learn, activate, and apply ourselves to the essential art of Zen practice-enlightenment that Dogen calls “nonthinking.” The authentic practice of Zen, according to Dogen, is the actualization of the universe (genjokoan), it is the intentional activity of “fashioning” a universe (and a self) that is lucid, harmonious, and free.
.
The “non” of nonthinking should not be confused with the “not” of not-thinking; nonthinking is inclusive of and transcendent to both thinking and not-thinking. For now the gist of the matter is this: “thinking” is the deliberate utilization of cognitive faculties, “not-thinking” is the ceaseless stream of (random, or chaotic) experience, and “nonthinking” then, is to think not-thinking, that is, to express the ultimate truth of all particular things (dharmas) through the practice of thinking (managing, utilizing) not-thinking (ceaseless experience).
.
To experience without the deliberate utilization of thinking is to be (exist as) an animal (an ox, or a cat), to experience deliberate not-thinking is to be a non-sentient thing (a rock, or a dead tree). At the same time, to experience nonthinking passively (as in cultic practices to “seek no goal” or “let things be as they are”) is to exist as a puppet; in Dogen’s terms, to be used by time rather than to use time, or to be turned by the Dharma rather than to turn the Dharma.
.
According to Dogen, no one can even begin to experience Zen without an intense aspiration to experience truth and an unqualified willingness to experience reality—all of reality as it truly is. To imagine one could achieve truth by denying or avoiding any aspect of reality, intellectual, emotional, instinctual, or otherwise is, in Dogen’s terms, to “be in delusion adding to delusion.” Dogen lauded the Sixth Zen Ancestor’s decision to leave his mother in order to meet the Fifth Ancestor, acknowledging the courage it must have taken for one with such a powerful emotional attachment. Ridiculing traditions that restricted females from participation or attendance because they might cause practitioners to “stray from the path,” Dogen quipped that perhaps males should also be restricted since they too could be “objects of sexual attraction.” The ceaseless stream of experience is the only material beings have for fashioning a universe and fashioning a self; the greater and fuller our experience the greater and fuller our existence. Therefore, not only is the universe fashioned uniquely according to the perspectives of individuals, but also according to the skills and depth of wisdom of individuals. Each being experiences the one mind uniquely, and the awakened being experiences it more accurately and deeply than the unawakened.
.
Now, let us give ear to the verse that the Venerable One spoke, specifically his lines, “Through my body, I have manifested the look of the Full Moon, thereby displaying the physical presence of all Buddhas.” Because the display of the physical presence of all Buddhas is a manifestation of one’s Spiritual Body, it has the look of the Full Moon. Accordingly, you need to grasp that all manner of tallness and shortness, as well as of squareness and roundness, are manifestations of your Spiritual Body. Those who are ever so ignorant of what this Spiritual Body is and of what manifesting It means are not only in the dark about the look of the Full Moon, they are not displaying the physical presence of all Buddhas. Foolish people fancy that the Venerable One provisionally displayed his body in some altered form, which is described as ‘the look of a full moon’, but this is an arbitrary and false notion of those who have not had the Buddha’s Way Transmitted to them from Master to disciple, for where or when would It possibly manifest as something separate from and independent of one’s body? What is important for you to recognize is simply that, at the time, the Venerable One was seated on the raised platform of a Dharma teacher. His body showed itself in the same manner as the body of anyone sitting here now, for this body of ours is, in fact, a manifestation of the Moon at Its full. His manifestation of the Spiritual Body is beyond being something square or round, beyond something existing or not existing, beyond something hidden or revealed, beyond something consisting of eighty-four thousand components: it is simply the manifestation of his Spiritual Body. ‘The look of the Full Moon’ describes the Moon implied in Fuke’s remark, “Right here is where the What is, whether the matter is put clumsily or delicately.” Because this manifestation of his Spiritual Body is rid of any arrogant pride, It goes beyond his being Nāgārjuna; It is the physical presence of all Buddhas. Because he displayed It, his Spiritual Body passes through and beyond the physical presence of all Buddhas. Hence, It has no connection with whatever may be on the periphery of the Buddha’s Way.
.
Although there is the Unbounded Radiance which takes some form like ‘the Moon of Buddha Nature at Its Full’, It is beyond what is commonly construed as ‘the look of a full moon’. And what is more, Its real functioning is beyond what is said or how it is put, and the manifestation of this Spiritual Body is beyond the physical and the mental, beyond the realm of the skandhas. Although It completely resembles the realm of the skandhas, It displays Itself by means of them, for this realm is the physical presence of all Buddhas. The Buddhas are the skandhas which give expression to the Dharma; the Unbounded Radiance has no set form. Further, when Its not having any set form is evinced by the meditative state that has no attachments, this is a manifestation of one’s Spiritual Body. Even though our whole assembly may desire to see ‘the look of the Moon at Its full’, this is something one’s eyes have never seen before. It is the turning point for the skandhas, which will give voice to the Dharma, and it is the absence of any fixed way in how the Dharma is stated or what form It may take, while the Spiritual Body manifests freely as It will. Its very ‘being hidden from sight’ and Its very ‘being openly displayed’ is Its stepping forward and stepping back in a cyclic manner. At the very time when Nāgārjuna’s Spiritual Body was manifesting Itself freely as he sat upon his platform, the whole assembly merely heard the words of the Dharma and did not perceive the ‘look’ of their teacher.
.
The Venerable Kānadaiba, who was Nāgārjuna’s Dharma heir, clearly recognized the Full Moon, the perfection of that Full Moon, the manifestation of Nāgārjuna’s Spiritual Body, the look of all Buddhas, and the physical presence of all Buddhas. Although there were many within the assembly who had entered the Master’s private quarters and had had the Buddhist Teachings poured into them, none could stand head-and-shoulders with Kānadaiba. Kānadaiba was respected for his Master’s sharing the Dharma seat with him, and he functioned as a teacher and guide for the whole assembly, since his partial seat was the whole of the Dharma seat. In that he had had the great, unsurpassed Dharma of the Treasure House of the Eye of the True Teaching authentically Transmitted to him, it was just like the Venerable Makakashō occupying the chief Dharma seat on Vulture Peak.
Shobogenzo, Bussho
, Hubert Nearman
.
For Dogen, seeing the full moon, like seeing a dust mote, is seeing the whole universe. To experience the “full moon” as “all manner of tallness and shortness, as well as of squareness and roundness” is to experience a realer, grander, and more accurate full moon than that of a round white disk in the sky. Its existence is realer and more accurate because the experience that goes into fashioning it is clearer and more abundant. The reason the assembly does “not perceive the ‘look’ of their teacher” is because the masses prefer to think the moon exists independently of their experience of it, and thus independent of their responsibility. The flat white disk in the sky is an isolated, abstract, impersonal thing. Zen masters, including Dogen, also see the disk, just as they see the mote of dust, but they see it completely. This kind of seeing requires us to see with all our capacities of experience. This kind of seeing is not done by thinking or by not-thinking, but by nonthinking which includes and transcends both. The masses see the full moon as an abstraction (which is always a subtraction) of reality, the Zen master sees the full moon as a demonstration of the infinite tangible aspects of reality.
.
For Dogen, and all the classic Zen masters, enlightened vision or wisdom (bodhi prajna) is the criterion of “normality” (the “ordinary mind). “Foolish people” are “in the dark about the moon” insofar as mediocrity, ambiguity, or generalization is seen as the standards of “normality.” The bonds of self-centeredness, sloth, and fear lead many, who are otherwise astute, reasonable, and intelligent, to accept simplistic “interpretations” that subvert the intention of Dogen’s (and Zen’s) teachings on the “normal mind” (ordinary mind, everyday mind). Rather than seeing that the “ordinary” is Buddha, they opt to see the “Buddha” as ordinary.
.
Why? If the ego-centric, indolent, and timid can subtract enough precision and definition from the real forms of the myriad dharmas they can reassure each other of the validity of their (common) views—and comfortably dismiss the assertions of the visionary (and the responsibilities such assertions imply).
.
Attempting to prune away all the aspects of the full moon so one’s views harmonize with the majority that sees only a “round disk” is only accomplished by blinding oneself. Once, when Dogen was in China, he saw a depiction of the Zen ancestors painted on the wall inside a temple. The panel that was supposed to represent Nagarjuna simply showed a circle. Dogen asked:
.
“Just what kind of transformation is this?” The guest supervisor says, “It is Nāgārjuna’s body manifesting the form of the round moon.” In saying this he has no nostrils in his complexion and no words in his voice. I say, “This really seems to be a picture of a rice cake!” At this the guest supervisor laughs loudly, but there is no sword in his laughter to break the painted cake.
Shobogenzo, Bussho
, Gudo Nishijima & Mike (Chodo) Cross
.
The guest supervisor’s laugh reveals that he sensed Dogen saw the truth—but there was no sword in his laughter. In other words, the laugh attempted to hide his ignorance—and imply that his view agreed with Dogen’s (whatever it might be). Thus, even when faced with the possibility to discover truth, some would rather be “mistaken as wise” than actually get at truth—at the risk of revealing their “ignorance.” As observed earlier, Dogen lamented that “Zen” was often misconstrued as being anti-intellectual. According to Dogen, this misled some to believe that study and clear understanding was not a requirement for authentic Buddhist practice. Dogen’s refutation of such notions is presented with no uncertain terms in his discussion on Nagarjuna manifesting the form of the moon.
.
Other skinbags who hear our talk also have nothing to say. Former and recent heads of the dining table are not perplexed to see [the picture] and they do not correct it. They probably could not even paint it themselves… because [people] do not wake up from views and opinions that the buddha-nature is related with the thinking, sensing, mindfulness, and realization [described] now, they seem… to have lost the boundary of clear understanding. Few even learn that they should speak the words. Remember, this state of neglect comes from their having stopped making effort. Among heads of the table in many districts there are some who die without once in their life voicing the expression of the truth “the buddha-nature.” Some say that those who listen to teachings discuss the buddha-nature, but patch-robed monks who practice Zen should not speak of it. People like this really are animals. Who are the band of demons that seeks to infiltrate and to defile the truth of our buddha-tathāgata?
Shobogenzo, Bussho,
Gudo Nishijima & Mike (Chodo) Cross
.
As we saw in our examination of the interaction between the experienced and the experiencer, in Dogen’s cosmology there can be no real distinction between voluntary and involuntary actions; our true self is as responsible for beating the heart as for smiling or going to the mailbox. However, in the worldview of cults that minimize or dismiss the role of intellectual effort in Zen, “experience” is regarded as something that “happens to us,” rather than something “we participate in.” To the “no goal” cults, seeing and hearing are not the activity of a true self transiting inward and outward, forward and backward fashioning a universe and a self. For them, seeing and hearing are simply inflicted on beings from somewhere “external” to or “other than” the being’s “self.” In such a view, “we” are nothing more than the hapless victim of our experience which is haphazardly thrust upon us by whatever environment we happen to be in. From such a worldview it is “normal” to see the “look of the full moon” as a white disk in the sky somewhat like a “rice-cake;” for such is the “normality” of general mediocrity.
.
To see the precise details and various characteristics of the full moon as Dogen, Kanadaiba, and all genuine Zen Buddhists do, demands focused, deliberate, enlightened effort—this is the normality of the Zen master (the ordinary mind of Zen). Such is not the focused, deliberate activity of the bean counter or the sniper, but the wholehearted attentive absorption of the child with a bin full of Lego’s, or the fly-fisherman at the mountain stream. The Zen practitioner that has genuinely cast off the body-mind (of self and other), that has genuinely glimpsed true nature (kensho), will not be satisfied to sit passively by allowing experience to simply “happen” as it will. The genuine practitioner has verified the truth expressed by Buddhas and ancestors—has awakened to the true nature of the universe and the self and personally experienced the true nature of freedom.
.
I am frequently questioned about the frequency with which my posts are involved with the consideration of "words." Here, in passing, let me be clear: the Buddha Dharma is words--and words are Buddha Dharma. The liberation of all beings always begins with words, moves on to meaning, then to experiential realization, which in turn is expressed as words. Thus, enlightenment is cast off, exerted, cast off, exerted as the continuous actualization of enlightenment based on enlightenment advances and actualizes the universe. With the certainty that experience is existence—is self creation—Zen practitioners can begin to develop the skillful means of experience, existence, creation—that is, the essential art of Zen.

-

Peace,

Ted Biringer

Tuesday, December 15, 2009

Dogen On Koans, Buddha Nature, & Practice

[Introductory Comment] The Bussho (Buddha-nature) fascicle, written by Zen Master Dogen, is one of longest fascicles in Shobogenzo, and also on of the richest. Its structure, as well as its context offer a wide variety of perspectives in which it can be read (e.g. as a single aspect of the whole Shobogenzo, as a 'unity' that stands on its own, as a collection of teachings on Buddha-nature, etc.).
-
While it is probably best to read it in context of the whole Shobogenzo (and Shobogenzo's context in the Zen/Buddhist literature), breaking it into parts seems more suitable for a blog.
-
In the following section of Bussho, Master Dogen cites two classic koans to illustrate some extremely profound implications of the Zen/Buddhist teachings on Buddha-Nature. In my view, this section of Bussho contains some of Master Dogen's most powerful, creative, and evocative uses of Zen koan literature in his entire corpus of writings. This particular section not only serves to illumine some remarkable, and often overlooked aspects of Buddha-Nature, it also provides a number explanations on the significance of Zen koans, practical instructions on how to approach them, and a whole array of clues on how they can be skillfuly used.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
[Begin Excerpt of Shobogenzo, Bussho]
Ōbaku was sitting in Nansen’s Abbatical reception room, when Nansen asked Ōbaku, “What do you think of the principle enunciated in the Great Scripture on the Buddha’s Parinirvana that, if one trains oneself equally in meditative practice and in spiritual wisdom, one will clearly see one’s Buddha Nature?”

Ōbaku replied, “Within all the hours of the day, It does not depend on a single thing, so we have It right from the start.”

Nansen said, “You aren’t saying this as the view of an elder monk, are you?”

Ōbaku replied, “I daren’t say so.”

Nansen said, “Setting aside for the moment the matter of payment for your rice broth, to whom are you to return payment for your straw sandals?”

Thereupon, Ōbaku remained silent.

‘Training equally in meditative practices and spiritual wisdom’ does not mean that, since training in meditative practices does not interfere with pursuing spiritual wisdom, Buddha Nature can be clearly seen when training in both equally. Rather, when we clearly see our Buddha Nature, then we will be training equally in meditation practice and spiritual wisdom. So Nansen stated, “What do you think of this principle?” This would be the same as saying, for instance, “Who is it that sees one’s Buddha Nature clearly?” Or it can be stated by saying, “How about the principle that Buddha Nature’s equal pursuit of both is what causes us to realize our Buddha Nature?”

The point of Ōbaku’s saying “Within all the hours of the day, It does not depend on a single thing” is that even though twenty-four hours exist within the span of a whole day, It is not dependent on them. Since Buddha Nature’s not depending on a single thing extends over all the hours of a day, It can be clearly seen. As to this ‘within all the hours of a day’ of his, would you ask at what specific time It will show up or in what country? These twenty-four hours that we are speaking of, would they have to be a human being’s twenty-four hour day? Or do they exist as a day in some other particular place? Or are they the kind of day that can occur for a while in Samantabhadra’s Silver Realm? Whether it be in this land or some other world, It does not depend on either. It is already within the twenty-four hours of any day and does not depend on anything.

Nansen’s asking, “You aren’t saying this as the view of an elder monk, are you?” is the same as asking, “You aren’t saying that this is your view, are you?” Although Nansen asked whether this is the view of an elder monk, Ōbaku should not turn to Nansen and affirm that it is indeed his own view. Although the statement was appropriate, it did not apply to Ōbaku alone, because Ōbaku is not the only person who held this view, as the views of many elder monks make abundantly clear.

As to Ōbaku’s replying, “I daren’t say so,” when someone in Sung China is asked whether he is capable of doing something, he uses this phrase, “I daren’t say so,” to acknowledge in a humble way his ability to do so. Thus, to say, “I daren’t say so,” does not mean that one doubts one’s abilities. What this expression says is not to be taken literally. Whether ‘the view of an elder monk’ refers to some other elder monk or whether ‘the view of an elder monk’ refers to Ōbaku, in either case the answer should be that he daren’t say so. It should be like a water buffalo coming out from the water and bellowing “Mu.” To put it like this is to affirm It. You should try and see if you can say, in your own words, the Principle that Ōbaku is affirming.

Nansen said, “Setting aside for the moment the matter of payment for your rice broth, to whom are you to return payment for your straw sandals?” In other words, the cost of your rice gruel is put aside for the moment, but who gets paid for the cost of your straw sandals? We should spend life after life exploring the intent of this statement through our training. We should keep our minds diligently investigating what he meant by ‘whatever the cost of the broth, don’t worry about it for the moment’. Why was he so concerned about the cost of straw sandals? It is as if he had asked, “In all the years that you have spent traveling as a mendicant monk, how many pairs of straw sandals have you worn out?” to which Ōbaku might answer, “If I had not paid back the cost, I would not still be wearing straw sandals,” or, then again, he might reply, “Two or three pairs.” Either way could be how he expressed the Matter. Each way would correspond to his intent.

The statement that Ōbaku thereupon remained silent simply means that he desisted from speaking. He did not remain silent because what he said was negated by Nansen, nor did he remain silent because he was negating what Nansen said. A patch-robed monk of true color is not like that. Keep in mind that silence speaks, just as laughter can wield a sword. This is Buddha Nature clearly seeing that there is enough gruel and enough rice.

In citing this story, Isan asked his disciple Kyōzan, “Don’t you think this shows that Ōbaku was no match for Nansen?”

Kyōzan replied, “Not so. We should recognize that Ōbaku had the wherewithal to capture the tiger alive.”

Isan said, “My disciple’s perceptiveness has excelled itself in this.”

What Isan was saying is, “Wasn’t Ōbaku able to match Nansen?” Kyōzan said that Ōbaku had the wherewithal to capture the tiger alive. If he had already captured the tiger, he could probably have stroked the tiger on its head. To capture a tiger and to pet a tiger are to engage in two totally different things. Is clearly seeing Buddha Nature the same as opening the Eye? Is one’s Buddha Nature seeing clearly the same as losing one’s Eye? Quick, quick, speak! The perceptiveness of Buddha Nature excels Itself in this. As a result, It does not depend on half a thing or on its whole. Nor does It depend on hundreds of thousands of things or on hundreds of thousands of occasions. For this reason it can be said:

The snares and traps of passion are but a single face of It.
On no time within a day does It depend, nor is It outside of time;
Rather, It is like wisteria and kudzu entwined about a tree.
All within the universe and the universe itself are still bereft of words for It, you see
.
~Shobogenzo, Bussho, Hubert Nearman - Online at:
http://www.shastaabbey.org/shobogenzo1.htm
[End Excerpt of Bussho]
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
[Closing Comment]
-
Dogen certainly offers up a rich and juicy harvest here, I am sure you will agree...
-
What do you make of Dogen's comment immediately following the first koan? In Dogen's language here, so it seems to me, utilizes that old reliable tool in the kit of all the great teachers: "a pretention to naiveté." In my experience, Dogen usually uses this tactic when he wants to be very sure that something is not overlooked or misunderstood. Notice how he carefully states and re-states the point that accurate "Training..." (even if authentic, like the "balanced" method mentioned here) does not mean that Buddha Nature can be seen. Notice also how is careful to state both, what that means, as well as what it does not mean. Here is the part:
-
"‘Training equally in meditative practices and spiritual wisdom’ does not mean that, since training in meditative practices does not interfere with pursuing spiritual wisdom, Buddha Nature can be clearly seen {even TB} when training in both equally..."
-
His manner of seemingly "overstating" the issue almost comes across in a way that a teacher might speak to a class of 1st graders--as if very clearly articulating the obvious. Thus he wipes away any dust and dirt, then makes a very clear, direct statement on what this does mean, here:
-
"Rather, when we clearly see our Buddha Nature, then we will be training equally in meditation practice and spiritual wisdom..."
-
It is notable that Dogen's emphasis on this point is not unique to the Bussho fascicle. He frequently stresses the fact that simply being able to perform Zen/Buddhist "practice" accurately is not the same as "authentic" practice-realization. This is often discussed in terms of a "non-Buddhist" Indian teaching of "Naturalism" (which is suspiciously very similar to some Tendai "Hongaku" teachings of Dogen's own place and time). These "non-Buddhist" teachings, by failing to fully incorporate the teachings of emptiness, nonduality, and coorigination fostered notions suggesting that since everyone is already, or "originally" enlightened, spiritual effort and practice was superfolous.
-
Such teachings were given some credibility at the time (and are widely active today) by mixing in a certain number of accurate views with the false ones. The most obvious, most damaging, and most difficult to uproot was (and is) based on the unity of "practice and enlightenment." The "non-Buddhist heretical view" included (includes) the "orthodox Zen/Buddhist" view that practice and enlightenment are (is) "one", but failed (fails) to apply the basic principles of nonduality which require the acknowledgement that the "oneness" of practice and enlightenment is dependent on the distinctions, or the "not-oneness" of practice and enlightenment.
-
In short, practice and enlightenment are nondual according to the "authentic Zen view"; thus, their "oneness" depends on the maintainence of their differing and distinct aspects; thus, "practice is practice-and-enlightenment", and "enlightenment is practice-and-enlightenment."
-
In the "non-Buddhist" view on the other hand, practice and enlightenment are fully merged--that is, each is viewed as substantially identical to the other; thus in the heretical view, "practice is enlightnment" and "enlightenment is practice." The unenlightened implications of this fallacy are not difficult to imagine.
-
I hope that this is useful.
-
Peace,
Ted